Generative resistance: Broadening the boundaries of research on resistance in information systems change

Joan Rodon, Mohammad Hosein Rezazade, Feliciano Sese

Producción científica: Capítulo del libroContribución a congreso/conferenciarevisión exhaustiva

1 Cita (Scopus)

Resumen

This paper proposes a new research perspective on resistance to information systems (IS) change. Drawing upon a power lens and complementing it with the organizational literature on resistance, we develop an integrative framework that conceptualizes resistance at three levels: 1) the non-compliance behaviors, 2) the meanings and norms that resisters contest and enact, and 3) the technical artifacts that resisters bring into their acts. By mapping existing IS literature on resistance onto our framework, we identify a bias of the literature towards a refusal view of resistance. That is, IS literature has been mainly concerned with resistance as a refusal behavior-i.e. refusal to a new system, to changes in the working practices, to loss of status quo-by which resisters attempt to neutralize the actions from the proponents of IS change. Yet our framework enables us to depict resistance not only as refusal but also as generative. Whilst a focus on resistance as refusal pays attention to the acts by which resisters aim to block the outcomes intended by the proponents of IS change, the analysis of the generative potential of resistance considers two additional aspects. First, it involves looking at how resisters challenge the meanings that proponents assign to the IS change-i.e. assumptions about the technology, goals and role of actors in the change process. Second, it entails analyzing how (human) resisters and technical artifacts become intertwined in the acts of resistance and how those socio-technical assemblages instigate disciplinary effects to the proponents of IS change. In other words, studying the generative potential of resistance involves viewing resistance as a socio-material accomplishment that may transform the established order through structural and radical changes.

Idioma originalInglés
Título de la publicación alojadaECIS 2012 - Proceedings of the 20th European Conference on Information Systems
EditorialAssociation for Information Systems
ISBN (versión impresa)9788488971548
EstadoPublicada - 2012
Publicado de forma externa
Evento20th European Conference on Information Systems, ECIS 2012 - Barcelona, Espana
Duración: 10 jun 201213 jun 2012

Serie de la publicación

NombreECIS 2012 - Proceedings of the 20th European Conference on Information Systems

Conferencia

Conferencia20th European Conference on Information Systems, ECIS 2012
País/TerritorioEspana
CiudadBarcelona
Período10/06/1213/06/12

Huella

Profundice en los temas de investigación de 'Generative resistance: Broadening the boundaries of research on resistance in information systems change'. En conjunto forman una huella única.

Citar esto