TY - JOUR
T1 - Accessible 2D video-based system for gait kinematic analysis
T2 - an inter-rater reliability study
AU - Puig-Diví, Albert
AU - Costa-Tutusaus, Lluís
AU - García-Gil, Juanjo
AU - Sartori, Francesco
AU - Picañol, Javier
N1 - Publisher Copyright: Copyright © 2026 Puig-Diví, Costa-Tutusaus, García-Gil, Sartori and Picañol.
PY - 2026/7/20
Y1 - 2026/7/20
N2 - Introduction – Quantitative gait analysis supports clinical decision-making and outcome monitoring, yet its use remains largely restricted to specialized laboratories due to cost and operational complexity. Smartphone-based two-dimensional video approaches using open-source software have shown promising validity, but inter-rater reliability—particularly the influence of examiner expertise across spatiotemporal and kinematic outcomes—remains insufficiently characterized in powered samples. Methods – In this observational study, 84 healthy adults were included and recorded during level barefoot walking using a standardized smartphone setup. Four examiners (two experienced, two non-experienced) independently extracted spatiotemporal parameters and hip, knee, and ankle joint angles at different gait events using Kinovea. Inter-rater reliability was assessed with intraclass correlation coefficients (two-way mixed-effects, absolute agreement; ICC [3, 1]) with 95% confidence intervals, and measurement error was quantified using the standard error of measurement (SEM) and minimal detectable change (MDC95). Agreement between expert and non-expert examiners was explored using Bland–Altman plots for representative variables. Mean values were descriptively compared with established three-dimensional reference values. Results – Global spatiotemporal descriptors demonstrated excellent reliability with minimal error and limited dependence on examiner expertise (walking speed ICC = 0.96; cadence ICC = 0.98; stride length ICC = 0.96). In contrast, temporal gait phase variables showed poor reliability overall (ICC ≈ 0.31–0.43), with higher—but still limited—agreement among experienced raters. Joint kinematics exhibited joint- and event-dependent reliability following a proximal-to-distal gradient: hip angles showed the highest consistency (ICC up to 0.88), knee angles moderate-to-good agreement (ICC ≈ 0.65–0.85), and ankle angles the greatest variability, particularly for event-dependent measures (e.g., opposite toe-off ICC = 0.45). Bland–Altman analyses revealed negligible bias for spatiotemporal outcomes but wider limits of agreement for kinematic variables. Mean values were biomechanically coherent, although systematic differences in joint angles were observed when compared with 3D reference data. Conclusion – In healthy young adults, a smartphone- and Kinovea-based workflow can provide reliable spatiotemporal gait metrics and moderate-to-good reliability for selected proximal kinematics, whereas temporal gait phase variables and distal joint angles remain less reliable and should be interpreted cautiously in longitudinal or multi-examiner contexts.
AB - Introduction – Quantitative gait analysis supports clinical decision-making and outcome monitoring, yet its use remains largely restricted to specialized laboratories due to cost and operational complexity. Smartphone-based two-dimensional video approaches using open-source software have shown promising validity, but inter-rater reliability—particularly the influence of examiner expertise across spatiotemporal and kinematic outcomes—remains insufficiently characterized in powered samples. Methods – In this observational study, 84 healthy adults were included and recorded during level barefoot walking using a standardized smartphone setup. Four examiners (two experienced, two non-experienced) independently extracted spatiotemporal parameters and hip, knee, and ankle joint angles at different gait events using Kinovea. Inter-rater reliability was assessed with intraclass correlation coefficients (two-way mixed-effects, absolute agreement; ICC [3, 1]) with 95% confidence intervals, and measurement error was quantified using the standard error of measurement (SEM) and minimal detectable change (MDC95). Agreement between expert and non-expert examiners was explored using Bland–Altman plots for representative variables. Mean values were descriptively compared with established three-dimensional reference values. Results – Global spatiotemporal descriptors demonstrated excellent reliability with minimal error and limited dependence on examiner expertise (walking speed ICC = 0.96; cadence ICC = 0.98; stride length ICC = 0.96). In contrast, temporal gait phase variables showed poor reliability overall (ICC ≈ 0.31–0.43), with higher—but still limited—agreement among experienced raters. Joint kinematics exhibited joint- and event-dependent reliability following a proximal-to-distal gradient: hip angles showed the highest consistency (ICC up to 0.88), knee angles moderate-to-good agreement (ICC ≈ 0.65–0.85), and ankle angles the greatest variability, particularly for event-dependent measures (e.g., opposite toe-off ICC = 0.45). Bland–Altman analyses revealed negligible bias for spatiotemporal outcomes but wider limits of agreement for kinematic variables. Mean values were biomechanically coherent, although systematic differences in joint angles were observed when compared with 3D reference data. Conclusion – In healthy young adults, a smartphone- and Kinovea-based workflow can provide reliable spatiotemporal gait metrics and moderate-to-good reliability for selected proximal kinematics, whereas temporal gait phase variables and distal joint angles remain less reliable and should be interpreted cautiously in longitudinal or multi-examiner contexts.
KW - gait analysis
KW - inter-rater reliability
KW - kinovea
KW - lower-limb kinematics
KW - spatiotemporal parameters
KW - two-dimensional analysis
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105046602089
UR - https://www.webofscience.com/wos/woscc/full-record/WOS:001837840800001
UR - https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14342/7176
U2 - 10.3389/fbioe.2026.1815411
DO - 10.3389/fbioe.2026.1815411
M3 - Article
C2 - 42548861
AN - SCOPUS:105046602089
SN - 2296-4185
VL - 14
JO - Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology
JF - Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology
M1 - 1815411
ER -